As
Israel prepares for the Annapolis summit with the Palestinians, an
internal conflict appears to be rapidly approaching boiling point.
Some have already named the looming threat a "Bedouin intifada."
Some 160,000 Bedouin live in Israel's southern region in
the Negev desert. Almost half of them live in large villages and small,
scattered communities that are unrecognized by Israel and are therefore
considered illegal. As a result, dozens of houses are demolished each
year by the Interior Ministry, while anger among the Bedouin community
mounts.
"It is really scary. I feel the pulse of the people and
the atmosphere is very, very tense," says Hussein Rafai'a, who heads
the regional council of the unrecognized villages.
Rafai'a says the situation is increasingly deteriorating
and the Bedouin leadership is finding it more and more difficult to
calm the atmosphere.
"The young generation is really edgy; they say 'we won't agree to this anymore,'" Rafai'a warns.
On October 28 Interior Minister Ze'ev Boim ordered the
establishment of an independent committee entrusted with solving the
Bedouin settlement problem. Boim appointed former state comptroller
Eli'ezer Goldberg to head the committee and asked him to submit his
recommendations within six months.
In the meantime Boim asked Attorney-General Menahem
Mazuz to freeze all demolishing orders, pending Bedouin commitment to
halt all illegal construction until the committee submitted its
recommendations.
A few days later anger and frustration among many in the
Bedouin community had risen to a dangerous level. The high hopes pinned
on the work of the committee were soon dashed at the sight of the
Interior Ministry's bulldozers.
"When we saw more houses destroyed even after the
committee was established, many young people were extremely furious,"
Rafai'a says.
"We are only human beings and there is a limit to what
we can absorb. The destruction of houses has repercussions not only on
the house-owner himself but on the entire society, which is a tribal
society with close interrelations," Rafai'a explains.
A Bedouin intifada
'Ali Abu Shheita, 46, is a resident of A-Ghrein, a
village which was recently recognized by Israel. Nevertheless, his
house – as well as houses belonging to a few dozen neighboring families
–earlier this year received a demolition order from the Interior
Ministry.
Abu Shheita explains that Israel only recognizes houses
in A-Ghrein, which belong to the A-Sayyid clan, while houses belonging
to his clan, Al-'Uqbi, have been left unrecognized.
Abu Shheita appealed to court, and in May he managed to
receive an order to freeze the demolition until the court reconvenes on
January 3, 2008.
His family, however, is far from feeling at ease.
"My wife and kids are panicked. My wife calls me every
hour. If I go to work and I see a contractor passing by with a
bulldozer, I accompany him until I see him leaving the village. Only
then can I calm down and go to work," Abu Shheita says.
Abu Shheita's children share a constant fear of the bulldozers, and the results are evident.
"You see the hatred in the house towards the state of
Israel. Even when the Israeli national football team plays abroad, my
children always cheer for the rival team," he says.
On May 18, 2004 the Israeli parliament's Committee on
Children's Rights held a meeting. On the agenda was the treatment of
children who are traumatized by the destruction of their homes.
Following the meeting, head of the committee, MP Michael
Melchior, stated that, "the destruction of children's houses in
response to illegal construction is a catastrophe."
Melchior continued: "There is no doubt that children,
who see their homes destroyed in front of their eyes, experience trauma
which leaves them with life-long scars."
Tamar Rabino, a clinical psychologist in the Health Ministry, was present during the meeting.
"As a professional authority in the therapeutic field, I
wish to express my shock at the fact that the state is causing trauma
[through the act of demolition]… it is the soul that they are
destroying here… It seems to me that this trauma is something absurd
and highly dangerous, and something must be done to prevent it," Rabino
said at the meeting.
Abu Shheita's daughter, Hedaya, is 19-years-old. Two months ago she saw her neighbors' house demolished.
"The children were left without a home, without anything. I saw how they felt and I wanted to help them, mentally," she says.
Although she was accepted to Ben-Gurion University,
where she was to study to become a teacher, Hedaya changed her mind.
She decided she would not study at the university, which is located
only few miles from her village, and instead applied to the University
of Amman in Jordan, where she now studies psychology.
Talking to The Media Line from Amman, Hedaya expressed her grave concerns for the future.
"The children are now small. They see the police come and destroy
their homes, so what do you expect will become of them in the future?
Will they love Israel or hate it?" Hedaya asks rhetorically.
Both Hedaya and her father strongly believe that if
nothing changes soon the Bedouin children of today will become easy
prey for extremists tomorrow. Hedaya has no doubts that if anyone tries
one day to recruit these children to commit terrorist acts, the
children would volunteer. In order to help prevent this from happening,
Hedaya wants to complete her psychology degree and return home before
things get out of hand.
"I am not looking for money; I just want to help these traumatized children," she says.
But Hedaya will only finish her studies in 2011. Meanwhile, her father fears conflict will blow up.
"A year ago I was quoted in a local newspaper as saying
that if the state of Israel does not take a sharp turn in its attitude
toward the Bedouin, an intifada will erupt,” he says.
The term intifada was adopted by the Palestinians to
describe their armed popular resistance. Hearing this term in the
context of the Bedouin was alarming to the authorities.
"I was taken to an investigation by the General Security
Organization [Shin Bet]. I made it clear to them that I wasn't
threatening; I was merely cautioning," he says.
So far, the Bedouin community in the Negev remains
quiet. Nevertheless, if ever they decide to change their ways, the
Bedouin have the potential to become a major internal threat to Israel.
The vicinity of many Bedouin villages to the southern
end of the West Bank, combined with relationships by marriage to
Palestinian citizens, make it easier for Palestinian terror
organizations to attempt to recruit Bedouins. Furthermore, the
apprehension of weapons is relatively easy as a result of smuggling
activities from across the Egyptian border.
Israeli intelligence has, in the past, expressed its
concerns regarding cooperation between the Bedouin and the terrorist
organizations in the Palestinian territories. Last year a young Bedouin
attempted to kidnap an Israeli female military officer. Also, in the
past few years, a few Bedouin have been arrested and charged with
purchasing weapons and selling them to Hamas.
The Shin Bet did not wish to reply to The Media Line's
questions regarding the cooperation between the Bedouin and the
Palestinian terrorist organizations. A source in the southern district
of the Border Police admitted that this kind of cooperation was known
to the police, but that no increased activity had been observed
recently.